NYRI: Negative impact on property values unlikely

NORWICH – Studies vary on the impact of power lines on nearby property values, according to local experts and a report in New York Regional Interconnect’s latest application filing.

While some studies cited in the NYRI report claim that transmission lines have little to no effect on home sales, which drive property values, others in that same report indicate there could be a significant decrease – in some cases between 2 and 10 percent – depending on how close the house is.

The filing is currently being reviewed by the state’s Public Service Commission under what’s known as Article VII, the power line permit review process. In one section, it claims the nearby Marcy-South power line did not have a “significant” impact on property values.



Prepared by an engineering firm hired by NYRI, the report eventually concludes that, “In short, most studies conclude proximity to a HVTL (High Voltage Transmission Line) per se does not necessarily lead to a drop in the value of surrounding properties.”

David Adams, one of three assessors for the Town of Norwich, believes that a high voltage line like NYRI’s could negatively impact home values in certain instances.

“It depends what kind of line it is. A high voltage line like that, if it runs down the middle of your property, typically knocks off about 30 percent,” said Adams, basing that assertion on information he’s gathered from state assessor classes.

In the Town of Norwich, properties in the Warner Road housing development off Polkville Hill, which borders the NYRI right of way, could be hit the hardest, Adams said.

“Those people have some concerns,” he said. “Theirs are the most legitimate concerns.”

Discuss this story with other members on the Forum


There's more to this story! You're only seeing 41% of the story. Subscribe now to get immediate access to the rest of the story as well as our whole online offering.

Today's Other Stories



Reader Response

2 comments on this story

dss
March 7th, 2008 at 1:49 pm
NYRI is not kidding. And while common sense screams that 10-story-high powerlines anywhere near a house are going to make that house less appealing, decision-making bodies like the PSC like to be able to quantify things with "studies" by "experts," however biased those "experts" may be. That's why NYRI bought and paid for a "study" that "proves" its point. A lot will depend on whether NYRI opponents can offer a credible study -- not just anecdotes or "it's obvious" arguments -- to demonstrate that property values will be diminished. So direct your attention to CARI, the lead opposition organization, and press them to engage expertise to produce such a report. Don't assume the "obvious" will prevail.
March 6th, 2008 at 6:40 pm
Are they kidding. This has to be a joke. The first thing I look for when buying a house[or land]is if there are power lines on the property, this is something I find "aesthetically pleasing"- NOT! I can't believe the NYRI would even include this in their filing. Sadly the NYRI is not joking. They will try anything to get this monstrous idea passed. Isn't there a study that states there appears to be a correlation between increased risk of developing childhood cancers and living near high power lines?
Please log in to leave a comment.
© 2008 Snyder Communications/The Evening Sun
29 Lackawanna Avenue, Norwich, NY 13815 - (607) 334-3276