By the time this appears, the Hostess Twinkies strike may be settled. Or… it will not be settled. And the company may be kaput.
In case you have missed it, the Twinkies story is simple. The company cannot afford to pay its workers all the pay and benefits the unions have negotiated. They cannot afford to pay the money and benefits the unions demand.
The company has been through Chapter 11. Twice in ten years. It said it cannot pay the medical and pension costs as demanded by unions. Those costs have been climbing. Sounds a bit like the auto companies, eh?
Over 18,000 workers will be out of their jobs. Thirty-three factories will close. Also losing out will be delivery drivers, companies that provide services to the factories, etc.
The head of the AFL-CIO blamed management, of course. He blamed crony capitalism. Although there was zero evidence of such. He suggested the owners would profit by the collapse. Right.
You may love unions. You may hate them. Wherever you stand, a few items ought to be obvious. One is that the company could not afford the union’s demands.
Call the contract unfair. Call it slavery. Call it too generous. You know, it really does not matter. The reality – the reality – is that the company could not afford the union’s demands. Basically, it said to workers: If you want to work here, here is what we can afford. If you demand more, we close.
They demanded more. Twinkies closed. It was a matter of the union standing strong, standing stubborn. The union called the company’s bluff. The company had no bluff. It said it had two pair. When the union called the bluff, the company showed its two pair.
The union bosses can raise their fists and claim mistreatment for workers. The reality is, the company could not afford what the union demanded.
The union bosses can claim managers did a lousy job. Does not matter. Over 18,000 people are out of their jobs. Because the company could not afford what the union demanded.
The bosses can claim capitalists were bleeding the firm. This does not make sense. Because, duh, capitalists do not like to see their investments go down the toilet. And so what? The reality is that over 18,000 folks are out of a job. And the capitalists are out of a company.
This is an old story. Many businesses have been poisoned by unreasonable unions. Many industries have been stymied and hampered. They have been handcuffed from changing with the times. Handcuffed by obstinate unions. The workers, the union leaders, have pumped their fists in the air and cursed the capitalists. And the capitalists have folded their tents.
Who was unreasonable here? Does not matter, does it? Over 18,000 folks are out of work. And a business has collapsed. It probably did not have to happen. That is what matters.
From Tom ... as in Morgan.
For more columns and for Tom’s radio shows and new TV shows (and to write to Tom): tomasinmorgan.com.