Complaint filed against private EMS for operating during ambulance shortage

NORWICH – A complaint has been filed with the state Health Department against Cooperstown Medical Transport (CMT) for allegedly operating in Chenango County without a permit.

CMT, based in Delaware and Otsego counties, is in the early stages of seeking approval to expand its EMS certificate into Chenango. In the meantime, the company has been operating in the county on occasion at the request of local leaders and EMS officials as they sort out the area’s ongoing ambulance shortage.

Margaret McGown, CMT’s chief financial officer, confirmed Thursday that a complaint has been lodged against the company.

Aside from heavy speculation, it has not been confirmed who filed the complaint. CMT has not been officially notified by the Department of Health, McGown added, so it’s not clear what, if any, violations have occurred or what possible penalties might be.



“We will do whatever the Department of Health asks us to do,” she said. “If that means not posting (being on-call) in Chenango County until the certification process is complete, then that’s what we’ll do.”

The Department of Health did not return a message seeking comment Thursday.

The complaint will “absolutely” not squash CMT’s plans to expand its ambulance service into Chenango County, McGown said.

“Any rumor that we’re going to pull-out now is absolutely incorrect,” she said. “We are going to continue what we’ve been doing. We’re going right along with plans as is.”

CMT has filed to expand its existing operating certificate with the regional arm of the Health Department in Binghamton. If approved there, the recommendation will be forwarded on to Albany to make a final decision. The process will take a minimum of three months, McGown said.

Discuss this story with other members on the Forum


There's more to this story! You're only seeing 45% of the story. Subscribe now to get immediate access to the rest of the story as well as our whole online offering.

Today's Other Stories



Reader Response

7 comments on this story

norwichreader
November 12th, 2007 at 10:53 am
From what I understand, a CON both says the ambulance is qualified to provide either als or bls level of service, and it prevents too many ambulances from operating in any given area. Since they have a CON for other areas, they are qualified. (And they said they had a CON in the works for this area.) As to too many ambulances in this area, don't make me laugh.
I don't want to run the guy who reported them out of town, but I don't support his actions in this case and I sure hope he considers his actions in the future.
odon11
November 10th, 2007 at 11:40 pm
The webcast of the meeting is online and available for everyone to see for themselves. It shows that nobody shut down CMT or even tried to. It shows the person voting YAY to giving them the emergency CON. It shows that the state makes the final decisions, not one person, not the dispatchers, or others looking for their own personal gain.

There are few people who are trying to run one man out of the EMS system, spreading fear through the community by spreading rumors and lies.
manfromoxford
November 10th, 2007 at 11:20 pm
The law is the law, and when someone has a duty to report it what do you expect them to do? Would you expect a cop to ignore a robbery or a firefighter to not report a fire? This is really for their protection as much as the protection of the people of this county. This sin't about mutual aide to Bainbridge and Afton. This is about posting in the middle of thcounty. They are probably lucky it was this individual andnot someone else who reported it. ANd if you ahd a prosecutor who really wanted to make a name for himself, he might weven be able to come up with conspiracy charges that implicate the County coordinators, CMT and the people who allowed them to post where they are rumored to have posted.
Yes, we need something done, but laws are laws no matter how much of a pain in the neck they are. We are deep in uncharted territory here and are going to be setting statewide precedent. People need to procede cautiosly and if you are untrained then be quiet while the big people are talking.
Rainman
November 10th, 2007 at 6:20 pm
Yeah, Sure, He is a pillar of the community. I think just about everyone in the county knows the truth. And its still amazing that 3 or 4 people defend the actions of a man bent on EMS his way or no way.
odon11
November 9th, 2007 at 8:40 pm
You're both wrong. The person who filed the complaint was one of the people who voted to approve the CON for CMT. The squad the person belongs to is more than capable of getting an ambulance or two out in a timely manner.
I wish everyone would find out the truth before bashing someone based on rumors and lies.

edwardsw
November 9th, 2007 at 2:05 pm
I have to agree with "randall375". This county is in a critical situation for ambulance coverage and CMT came to the plate to help out. Why would anyone in their right mind complain about that. From I've heard the complainat originated from a member of a volunteer agency who can't even get their ambulance out on calls in a timely manner themselves. I would really like to know this individuals problem was with this critical need fixed. Lets hope he or she does not assistance or a family member and they have to wait 1/2 to an hour to an ambalance.

Regarding the fly car proposal what good is that, the county need the ability to transport. Most areas have a first response unit to respond immediately to wait for transportation. The county should be looking at providing a transportation service if these other agencies do not get their CON.
randall375
November 9th, 2007 at 11:37 am
This figures... we are in desperate need of help here - they step up to the plate and lend a hand, and some jerk complains to the state. I hope the person who complained doesn't need service in the near future - or they may think twice.
Please log in to leave a comment.
© 2008 Snyder Communications/The Evening Sun
29 Lackawanna Avenue, Norwich, NY 13815 - (607) 334-3276